data center road trip // day 6-7
I don't think the data center backlash is about AI being evil or risky — but it does reflect people finding AI uniquely useless
for example: is the data center backlash just like the backlash to solar farms? @nicholas_bagley observed that both movements use classic NIMBY playbooks: Facebook groups, FOIA requests, packing city council. both also involve land use tensions between rural towns and state directives.
yet the Saline, MI activists I met were pro-solar farms and anti-data center. first, data center deals are more secretive with more NDAs and bigger $$ amounts. second, solar was supported by environmentalists even if hated by farmers: it generates power instead of consuming it
it seems pretty clear that AI lacks a strong pro faction or positive case. plenty of folks are agnostic on data centers, and plenty hate them, but the only people truly excited are tech billionaires and utility companies — the least sympathetic entities you could have on your side
jasmine sun (@jasminewsun)
I’m spending the next week driving around Wisconsin and Michigan to get a firsthand view of the data center buildout and backlash
am visiting sites, talking to tons of people — tradespeople, activists, planners, residents — then writing up a story
lmk what questions I should dig into!
— https://nitter.net/jasminewsun/status/2077519592130253200#m